ENVPL201 Assessment Report Overview

You will need to attend a District or Regional council resource management hearing during the semester, so that you can prepare this report. The purpose of the hearing report is to make you notice, record, and reflect on the key elements of planning under the Resource Management Act in the context of a resource management hearing.

You will attend/watch a hearing (as available) at a time which works best for you.

Get Organised Early – Hearing Dates:

Hearing dates cannot be fixed prior to the start of this course, as we need to receive notification from a council about when a hearing will be held. A hearings folder is provided in the assessment tab with resources and we have made a list of a few options for you to consider in the document: ‘Potential Hearings’.

You can also find out dates and times by phoning the hearings secretary for any district or regional council or from the public notices of the local papers. The dates will be for hearings at Hamilton City Council, Waikato District Council, Waipa District Council and Waikato Regional Council. If you prefer, you may attend a hearing in any other district or regional council, for example, a council close to where you live.

Many councils now have details of hearing agendas posted online in advance of a hearing. Search for the council and then “notified resource consents”, then find details of the hearing from the agenda. You may also attend Council hearings in relation to publicly proposed district and regional plans.

Go to the first Hearing that you can possibly get to. Although you have a couple months for this assignment, do not be lulled into thinking you can put it off and go later. Council resource consent hearings do not happen more than once a month, so if you want to go to a hearing in easy distance of the university, there are not many that come up in that time span.

Try and get to the hearing at the start, so that you can see and hear what happens. However, if you have a class or some other reason that makes you late, you can slip in quietly and it will be OK. If you come in late you will need to try and catch up on important information (such as councillors’ names, what the hearing is about, etc.) by getting a copy of the agenda and other useful information. Normally, a copy of the agenda for each hearing will be available in electronic form from the Council website or on Moodle.

You do not have to stay for an entire hearing, but make sure you stay for at least as long as it takes you to understand what is going on (this could be 2-3 hours). Try and find out the names and functions of the people you see. If you can’t see from name tags or from the discussion, wait for a tea break and ask the committee secretary or one of the councillors (Note: council hearings always break for lunch and morning and afternoon tea).

Council hearings are a serious business, please make sure you are respectful of protocol and polite at all times. Do not talk throughout the hearing and ensure your mobile phones are switched off. If you arrive early introduce yourself to the Council staff who are organising the hearing.

Because of COVID19 and advances in technology, it may be that hearings are held online. You are welcome to use recorded hearings (such as the ones referred to in the Hearings Information folder) if you are unable to get to a hearing. It is better experience for you to attend in person, but you can elect the format in which you attend/watch a hearing.

Guidelines Self-check

Wordcount: 2000 (+/-10%) not including reference list

Cover Page

Top right corner:

Provide your full name and Student ID, word count, the name of the Course, the title of the assignment (Resource Management Act Hearing Report)

Title:

Include the name of the Council, the type of hearing (e.g. a resource consent hearing or a hearing for a change/variation to a regional or district plan), the date and venue of the hearing, the name of the resource consent applicant(s) or district plan variation or plan change, the location of the site or the nature of the topic/issue that is the subject of the hearing, the type of consent (e.g. a subdivision or land use consent, a discharge permit or a coastal permit).

Introduction

Provide a brief overview of the issue/s that is/are the subject of the hearing and agencies and people involved. If possible, provide a location map of the site of the application. Make sure you clearly orientate the reader, identifying the RMA hearing process attended (e.g. resource consent/plan change/variation hearing)

a) Describe the physical surroundings and the people involved; note anything that catches your eye; identify who the various people are and what are their roles (e.g. councillors, committee secretary and other council staff, applicants or submitters, legal counsel, expert witnesses etc.); note any unusual characteristics (e.g. age, gender, ethnicity), and any interactions, communication, body language etc.; make what interpretations you can.

b) Note the reactions of listeners to particular speakers and see if you can see any relationship between the kind of reaction and the characteristics of the speaker (e.g. age, sex, dress, level of expertise, level of confidence, authority, social status etc.). Critically consider aspects such as these and discuss them in the context of the process and substance of the hearing.

c) Draw a diagram of the venue, showing the main physical features and who is sitting where. Scan or photograph your drawing to include it in the word document or create it in word/miro/canva etc as a smart art/figure. Alternatively, discuss the logistics of a Zoom hearing.

d) Describe your own reactions to the experience. (Remember that you, yourself, are an important source of information; chances are, the way you think, and feel is the way an ordinary member of the public is likely to think or feel. You can use your own reactions and responses as an indicator of the situation, and this can form an important part of your analysis.)

Rma And Planning Analysis:

Most importantly, comment on what you have learned about the Resource Management Act and planning – the following points should take up the bulk of your report:

SELF-CHECK

a) Try and relate what you see and hear to what you learn in your lectures. For example, explain what type of process you have witnessed.

b) Was it a plan hearing or a resource consent application? If it is a resource consent hearing, what is the point of the resource consent and what type of resource consent is it?

c) What do you understand in terms of the zoning and the category of activity?

d) How is the process carried out and how are the decisions made?

e) What is the role of the Purpose and Principles of the RMA? How did they affect the process you examined?

f) What have you discovered about environmental planning?

g) Is planning political?

h) Does power affect planning?

These are examples, and not all may relate to the process you examine. There are many different ways to explore the hearings process, relate it to your course content and analyse it. As well as showing you understand the process bring your own critical reflection to your report. Done well this will elevate your report to a top grade

Other Reminders:

Style:

Use your own language in writing the report. Write clearly and succinctly. Do not quote verbatim from the Hearing report unless you also give the reference, including the page number. Remember that plagiarism of all forms is forbidden. Your report will be filed through the Turnitin plagiarism detection software. Use APA referencing. It is a good idea to download and use the free Zotero or Endnote software available via the Library online.

Layout:

Use a report format with a cover page, contents page, introduction, conclusion, references, and appendices (if necessary). An executive summary is unnecessary. Use headings with bold font to show structure and thought. Use consistent line spacing. Number each page, by means of a ‘header’ or ‘footer’. Use A4 paper. Submit the report on Moodle, on or before the due date. Use a clear font such as Times New Roman, Calibri or Arial, font size 11/12.

Additional Requirement For ENVPL514 Students

SELF-CHECK

ADDITIONAL WORD COUNT:

1000 WORDS

1. Resource management reform:

Reflect on and discuss the purpose and importance of the hearings process. Finally, examine recent government proposals for resource management reform. Consider whether proposed reforms may be relevant to this hearing and how they may affect the processes/outcomes for people and the environment.

ENVPL201 Assessment Criteria

Your report will be assessed according to how successfully it fits the following criteria:

• The description is accurate, succinct, and to-the-point (your description should cover the essentials but not be weighed down by verbiage)
• Your analysis shows an understanding of the purpose, principles and relevant provisions of the RMA (e.g. they reference sections of the RMA, understand the activity status/plan change content, they understand the effects/AEE, reference s42A report).
• Key to A level grades Your comments and interpretations show an understanding of the hearing in relation to the RMA
• Key to A level grades Your report shows insight into the power and politics of planning
• The organisation of your report is clear, logical and easy to follow
• The layout and presentation of your report is well set out and easy to read and understand
• The report is accurately referenced in accordance with the APA/Chicago author date style.
• Extra for ENVPL514 only: Critical analysis of the role and value of hearings in resource management decision making. Demonstrates an understanding of relevant proposed reforms and their potential effects on resource management outcomes Key to A grades

Notes – a high quality report will do all of the above in a coherent, concise and critical way.